Former STL Tigers in their 2025 collegiate playoff include:

Max Harris at Doane University, Cade Seabaugh at Hope College, George Astacio at Central Baptist College, Wilser Then at Cumberland University (TN), Jonatan Clough at New Mexico State, Franklin Sosa at SWIC, Josh Rhiney at Fontbonne, Ian Feld at Grinnell, Michael Walsh at Lindenwood, and Harrison Bailey at Wheaton College.